Replica Sites Review

Marilyn Kaye wanted to share her tale for this one bag she got from three different sites: Bagaholics, Fabaaa and Beubag. Three different Proenza Schouler PS1, three different kinds of quality. Jury may begin deliberations.

“A tale of one bag, three sites!

I’ve been wanting a Proenza Schouler PS1 for ages, and I was very excited to see the bag offered by three different replica sites: Fabaaa, Beubag, and Bagaholics. I ordered one, in different colors, from each site. I live in France, which has notoriously strict customs regulations in regard to replica handbags, so I wasn’t even sure I’d receive all the bags. But I did, and here’s my tale.
Fabaaa was the easiest site to deal with. The transaction was simple, I could pay by credit card, and the bag was promptly shipped. It was also the cheapest of the three — $183, which included shipping. The bag that arrived wasn’t bad at all — well designed and executed, and the camel color was nice. The big problem was the quality of the leather — stiff to the touch, and cheap looking.
Beubag wasn’t as easy to deal with, although the correspondence was pleasant and polite. They had an inexplicable problem with my credit card, which was eventually cleared up, and in their concern to avoid the French customs, they sent the bag to the UK where it was then forwarded to me. Delivery took three weeks. This bag too was well-made, and while the quality of the leather was better than the bag from Fabaaa, it wasn’t the best quality. This was also the most expensive bag, $339.
The third bag, from Bagaholics, was delayed too, and I had to write the company several times to ask for updates. I received responses within 48 hours. I received the bag in approximately two weeks. It’s clearly the best of the three; again, the design, stitching, hardware, etc. were impeccable, but this time I had a bag with soft leather that felt like real lambskin and it came with two shoulder straps in different styles. The color, khaki, is gorgeous — a sort of grayish taupe with a slightly green overtone, which is almost indistinguishable from the authentic bag’s color ‘military.’ The bag cost $315, and it’s totally worth it.
I’m not returning any of the bags — they are all wearable, and the first two will be given as gifts to friends’ teenage daughters who are less picky about the quality of leather than I am! The third, from Bagaholics, I will carry proudly. And as soon as my bank account is replenished, I will be hitting the Bagaholics website again!”

Proenza Schouler PS1 Replica

Proenza Schouler PS1 Replica

Proenza Schouler PS1 Replica


Responses to: Reader Submitted Replica Site Review:, &

  1. emily ~ 10/14/2013 at 6:05 pm

    Thank you so much Eva for your response! :) Here are the one’s i’m considering. My priority is a saddle color, then smoke, then blue, then black. – is it true to the saddle color? – is this the smoke or just a grey? i want it to eventually turn brownish like smoke does. – this color looks perfect, but it looks suede not leather. i’m only looking for leather but the title is confusing me. – is this a good black or is it too shiny? this blue looks great but the coloring seems off. what do u think?

    please let me know the best one according to how real it looks with its color. Your opinion will definitely make my decision!! Thank you :)

    • Eva Knox ~ 10/15/2013 at 2:53 pm

      Here is what I think: – is it true to the saddle color? – No, it’s not the true saddle color. – is this the smoke or just a grey? i want it to eventually turn brownish like smoke does. – It’s not smoke, it’s just grey and it won’t change the color. – this color looks perfect, but it looks suede not leather. i’m only looking for leather but the title is confusing me. – This one is made of suede leather. – is this a good black or is it too shiny? – It’s a good black this blue looks great but the coloring seems off. what do u think? – The color is nice but it doesn’t look the authentic color.

  2. sabrina ~ 10/04/2013 at 3:49 am

    Hey eva

    what do u think about these two bags

    thank u ::))))

    • Eva Knox ~ 10/04/2013 at 2:52 pm

      They look really good but the interior pattern it’s a bit different than the authentic. It’s a minor flaw but if you can’t live with it, you should try another site.

  3. emily ~ 10/01/2013 at 5:05 pm

    Hi Eva! So do you suggest I purchase from ladyshopping instead of bagaholics? This will be my first replica purchase and my first proenza so I really have no idea which has the best quality bag/leather!

    • Eva Knox ~ 10/03/2013 at 11:34 am

      Yes, ladyshopping is better for this brand but you should check closely all the details. Give me the link to the bag you want from ladyshopping and I’ll let you know if it’s good or not! :)

  4. emily ~ 09/30/2013 at 8:05 pm

    What do you think about this bag? It seems like a saddle but I cannot tell! It’s from bagaholics as well.

    • Eva Knox ~ 10/01/2013 at 1:16 pm

      The bag look good, same as the color. The only small issue is the interior color, it should be grey with logos.

  5. Ken ~ 12/27/2012 at 6:54 pm


    Thanks so much for your hard work! The BagaHolics being to referred to, is it or


    • Eva Knox ~ 12/28/2012 at 2:08 pm

      It’s my pleasure! This is the site, :)

  6. Tara ~ 07/26/2012 at 12:57 pm

    Hi Eva,
    This site is fantastic! I’m new to all of this, but what site do you recommend for a medium PS 1? And can you also explain the whole customs clearance thing? Will I end up having to pay extra to get it? Thanks, girl! x

    • Eva Knox ~ 07/30/2012 at 4:02 pm

      The best site id, you can also find a review with pictures of a PS1. Replica sites, like PV guarantee delivery, this means that if you don’t receive your order for any reason they will make a reshipment at their own expenses. They also mark the packages as low value (gifts or samples) so they wouldn’t be inspected in customs. :)

      • Jenny ~ 08/09/2013 at 12:22 am

        Hi Eva, is there a new site for deluxepurse and is that the website that you still recommend for a ps1? Thanks!! By the way, love your site~~

        • Eva Knox ~ 08/13/2013 at 3:05 pm

          Yes, I still recommend deluxepurse for PS1 bags and their new site is

  7. Michelle ~ 12/06/2011 at 10:52 am

    Hi Eva,
    This was a very helpful review. I have been looking at the Proenza Shouler PS1 in many of the sites that you recommend but it is not available. I wanted to ask you if you know anything about
    Was thinking of ordering from them.

    • Eva Knox ~ 12/08/2011 at 3:12 pm

      For me, this site is a big NO! Why? How can a replica site guarantee their bags will clear customs anywhere in the world?! It’s absurd and a big lie! Let me know what you decide! :)

Leave a reply

× 9 = sixty three


Copyright 2015